Draining the Everflowing Chalice
or An Existential Look at My Letterboxd Watchlist
Art by Chris Seaman
As I write these words, there are 2,908 movies on my Letterboxd watchlist. They come from every stratum of the cinesphere: canon classics, cult whatsits, shot-on-video curios, and various flavours of cinematic junk food. There are movies on the list that I am apparently the last person on Earth to see and movies I’ve only heard of because they were referenced on a podcast episode exactly once. Up until a week ago, one of those movies was Some Kind of Heaven, Lance Oppenheim’s 2020 documentary about The Villages, Florida, a place that answers the question “what if Main Street USA was a whole city?” It’s such a sad and strange and beautiful film. It has vaulted to the top of my Favourite Films of 2020 list, knocking First and Last Men down to second and Tenet down to third. But Some Kind of Heaven also got me thinking about death in general, and my own death in particular. There’s something about seeing people, living in a simulacrum of their misremembered youth, trying to party like a person a quarter of their age that gets you thinking about the big losing battle we’re all waging.
This headspace is also informed by my recent reread of Oliver Burkeman’s Four Thousand Weeks: Time Management for Mortals, an existential anti-productivity book whose central conceit, in part, is “what do you really want to be doing with this one blessed life you have?” I cannot and will not do everything I want to do: my window for being, say, the next Roger Ebert has long closed. I will probably never dunk a basketball. There are many countries I will never visit (though quite a few are still on the table) and friends I will never have the pleasure of meeting IRL, and I have to be okay with that. So what am I doing with myself and my precious time? Outside my professional and domestic lives, my time gravitates towards three pursuits: writing, playing Scrabble, and watching movies. These are, in a sense, my three main hobbies. These are the things I want to do with my spare time. But I’ve been detected in my cinephile duties lately. YouTube has gobbled up a lot of my couch potato time, and movie-watching time has receded as a result. I want to change this. Specifically, I want to watch less stupid bullshit my various algorithms want me to see (Jubilee debate videos where one guy defends Neil Young’s 1982–88 run against 20 rabid record store clerks) and more stupid bullshit I choose myself (cheap Italian Mad Max ripoffs).
There was once a time, likely during grad school, when my cinephilia was the gravitational center of my life, where I told myself I wanted to watch 10,000 movies in my lifetime. This dream is dead. Unless, of course, I resume watching new-to-me movies at the same clip I was doing so in my 20s, and that’s just not happening, man. I work 40 hours a week and have a girlfriend and pets and other hobbies… I’ve got obligations! That bi-weekly poetry open mic isn’t going to co-host itself! Watching four, five movies a week is the province of critics and addicts. Two movies a week I can manage, three if I’m feeling spicy. Now for some arithmetic.
I’m about 18 months shy of my 40th birthday, so let’s say I’ve gone through half my allotted 4,000 weeks; 2,000 weeks down, 2,000 weeks to go. Let’s also say I aim to keep a perfectly reachable two movies per week for the rest of my life, which is 2 times 2,000, so we’re back at 4,000. 4,000 more movies to see, which I am relieved to say is well above the 2,900-odd movies currently waiting for their turn at bat in my watchlist. Let’s go ahead and factor in another 20 movies a year for the next 40 years to account for the movies yet made I will want to see and add those 800 hypothetical films to my watchlist. We’re still about 300 movies short of the cut-off. As big as this particular to-do list is, it’s not too big to tackle in the context of a life well spent at the movies.
The first time I made this calculation, I was overcome with a strange sense of peace. It was confirmation that I wasn’t biting off more than I could chew as a cinephile and as a person. Sure, I may not even make it to 80 (though I do have to note that I really, really would like to, he said knocking every wooden object in sight). And even if I do make it to decade number nine, there are going to be stragglers on that watchlist that never get seen. Sorry, Nymphomaniac: Vol II! But there is something soothing about having a durational personal project, a mountain of media to enjoy you can only move a spadeful of soil at a time.
So do the math. Wrestle with your own mortality in this benign way. Put a ceiling on your watchlist. Be judicious. Figure out how much you can bite off and start chewing.